If you would prefer to listen to an audio version of this post – please click here.
Consumer Confidence and Mortgage Rates - What's the Relationship?
Consumer confidence plays an important role in shaping the economy, influencing everything from consumer spending to mortgage rates. Yesterday, we learned that consumer confidence has taken a dip due to concerns about potential economic slowdowns, executive administration policies, and shifts in the housing market. But what does this decline mean for mortgage lenders, and how should they adjust their strategies?
In this article, we’ll break down:
- What consumer confidence is and why it matters
- How consumer confidence affects the economy and mortgage rates
- How mortgage lenders can respond strategically to shifting consumer sentiment
What is Consumer Confidence?
Consumer confidence is a leading economic indicator that measures how optimistic consumers feel about the state of the economy and their financial future. It is often tracked using the Consumer Confidence Index (CCI), which is based on surveys measuring people’s perceptions of their income, job security, and overall economic conditions.
How do you interpret key Consumer Confidence indicators?:
- High consumer confidence → Consumers feel secure in their jobs and finances, leading to increased spending and borrowing.
- Low consumer confidence → Consumers fear economic instability, resulting in reduced spending and borrowing, potentially leading to economic slowdowns.
Right now, consumer confidence is plummeting due to inflation concerns, new executive administration policies (and those forthcoming) and economic uncertainty—directly impacting mortgage lenders. So, it’s important to pay attention.
How Does Consumer Confidence Affect the Economy?
Consumer confidence is a leading economic indicator—meaning it can predict economic growth or contraction before it happens. It’s relatively simple to interpret – when consumers are optimistic, they spend more, boosting business growth, job creation, and real estate investments. When confidence drops, spending decreases, businesses slow down, and economic growth stagnates.
Consumer Confidence and the Housing Market
So why then when consumer confidence drops does the housing market typically slow down? Here’s why:
- Less demand for home purchases – Consumers delay major financial decisions, such as buying a home.
- Fewer mortgage applications – Uncertainty leads to a decline in new mortgage originations.
- Increased lender risk – Lenders may tighten approval requirements, making it harder for some borrowers to qualify.
On the flip side, a sudden rise in consumer confidence can lead to a surge in home buying, pushing home prices higher and increasing mortgage demand.
How Consumer Confidence Affects Mortgage Rates
Many mortgage lenders rightfully focus on interest rates, housing supply, and inflation, but consumer confidence, often overlooked, has proven to be just as important in predicting market trends.
Let’s examine how Consumer Confidence impacts mortgage rates:
- Low consumer confidence = Potential lower mortgage rates
- If consumers stop or drastically slow spending, the Federal Reserve may cut rates to stimulate economic activity.
- Mortgage lenders may adjust rates downward to encourage borrowing.
- High consumer confidence = Potential higher mortgage rates
- More spending means consumer confidence is healthy and the economy is strong, leading to higher inflation and rising mortgage rates.
What’s the takeaway?: Keeping an eye on consumer confidence trends can help mortgage professionals predict where rates may be headed next.
What Should Mortgage Lenders Should Do When Consumer Confidence Drops?
#1 - Monitor Economic Indicators Closely
Mortgage lenders should track consumer confidence reports, job market trends, and inflation data to anticipate changes in borrower behavior.
Unsure where to source this data? Here are links to reputable sources on each category:
1. Consumer Confidence: The Conference Board
2. Job Market Trends: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics
3. Inflation Data: U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis
#2 - Adjust Marketing & Messaging to Address Borrower Concerns
During periods of low consumer confidence, borrowers need reassurance and an injection of hope. Mortgage lenders should:
- Highlight affordability options – Promote lower down payment programs or rate buydown options.
- Offer financial education – Help borrowers understand why buying a home during market uncertainty can still be a smart investment.
- Showcase refinancing options – For hesitant buyers, refinancing tools can offer future flexibility.
Pro tip: Invest in AI-powered mortgage presentation software that can fulfill these capabilities quickly and efficiently without having to spend hours building reports and crunching the numbers.
#3 - Strengthen Client Relationships & Build Trust
In uncertain and oscillating financial times, personalized borrower engagement is key. Mortgage lenders who build trust offer:
- Regular market updates (use The Mortgage Minute to follow market trends)
- One-on-one consultations
- Custom mortgage solutions
Pro tip: The more proactive and transparent mortgage professionals are, the more likely they are to secure long-term clients and future referrals—even in uncertain markets.
Learn to Stay Ahead of Market Shifts
Understanding how consumer confidence affects the economy helps mortgage lenders who look to navigate uncertain markets strategize more effectively. When confidence drops, consumer behavior shifts, impacting mortgage demand and rates.
Pro tip: Mortgage lenders who stay informed and engaged, adapt their marketing strategies, and proactively support borrowers can continue to thrive—no matter the market conditions.
Want more mortgage market insights? Subscribe to The Mortgage Minute for real-time updates and expert strategies. We deliver our weekly email newsletter covering the mortgage industry straight to your inbox each and every Monday morning!
About The Author
